Motorcycles are providing job opportunities for Kenya’s youth. But criminals find these vehicles versatile in a number of ways, and are using young people and their bikes for their own gain.
On 13 October 2021, Jibril Hassan Edin, Issack Hassan Ibrahim, Rooney Jahwan Elisha, Stephen Munga Iogo and Kelvin Omboke Otieno were arraigned in a Nairobi court and charged with stealing 169 motorcycle worth US$180 044 (KES 20 300 000). In court proceedings, the Directorate of Criminal Investigations stated that the suspects were part of an organised crime group that recruited jobless youth who had an interest in getting into the motorcycle transport business, known as boda boda in Kenya.
In 2009, Kenya’s government zero-rated the duty on motorcycles in an effort to provide employment to its youth, who use the bikes to provide public transport. Kenya currently has around 1.4 million public transport motorcycles supporting five million Kenyans and generating US$3.2 billion (KES 357 billion) annually. Public transport motorcycles in Kenya have plugged a big gap in youth unemployment, with riders earning at least US$8.87 (KES 1 000) a day.
However, links between the motorcycle industry, unregulated loan sharks and cross-border crime are worrying.
The recruitment of the jobless youth begins when unregulated loan sharks identify potential targets and provide them with motorcycle loan deposits that amount to US$133 (KES 15 000). This enables the youth to acquire the bike and commits them to paying the balance of US$1 196 (KES 135 000) over 18 months. The loan sharks trace these loanees, organise for the motorcycles to be stolen and then smuggle them into Ethiopia over the Moyale border, leaving the youth with the loan burden. These motorcycle syndicates rely on contract law, which states that written debt contracts or signed loan contracts are enforceable. This obliges loanees (the youth) to pay for motorcycles even after they have been stolen and smuggled into Ethiopia.
Guyo Turi, an independent researcher based in Marsabit County, told ENACT that motorcycle smuggling to Ethiopia has been exacerbated by an influx of cheaper Chinese and Indian-made motorcycles into Kenya, as well as a high demand in Ethiopia where motorcycles are used for personal transport, to ferry goods to local markets and as taxis. He said the Moyale border point on the Kenyan side had a growing illicit market in motorcycles and spare parts (including tyres), which are supplied to southern Ethiopia.
While some bikes stolen in Nairobi and other parts of Kenya are smuggled whole, others are dismantled in urban garages in Eastleigh and Kariobangi before being packaged and transported in buses and trucks that travel the Nairobi-Moyale route. These are then re-assembled in garages at Moyale and smuggled into Ethiopia through Forolle, an unmanned border point. Here, transporters (trucks and buses) operating along the Kenya-Ethiopia border appear to be complicit in the illicit motorcycle market in Moyale, Ethiopia.
A Nairobi-based security consultant told ENACT that youths’ desperation and the lack of regulation of both the motorcycle industry and credit firms contribute to the theft and smuggling of bikes from Kenya to Ethiopia, and in turn a highly-organised, profitable criminal association. He said Kenyan youth in urban centres were increasingly desperate due to the lack of jobs. The boda boda industry offers these youths an immediate income.
Many urban-based loan sharks have set up these profitable businesses. As noted, they provide credit to young people by lending them money to buy the bikes and thus hope of an income. Yet when these bikes are stolen the youth still owe the loan sharks, they are then trapped in debt but are now worse off as their source of income has vanished.
The bikes appear to be used in other criminal activities too. A recent study by the National Crime Research Center in Kenya reported connections between the rapidly expanding public service motorcycle industry and other well-coordinated organised crime syndicates such as human trafficking and cannabis smuggling from Sheshamane in Ethiopia to Moyale in Kenya.
So too in Busia town along the Kenya-Uganda border, criminals use public service motorcycles as their preferred getaway vehicles. According to the National Crime Research Center the crimes that are perpetrated using these bikes include the theft of motorcycle parts, assault, robbery with violence, handling and trafficking of drugs and smuggling of goods.
While calls have been made to regulate the public motorcycle industry in Kenya, similar calls are needed to enforce the Micro and Small Enterprise Act of 2012 that regulates the micro-credit industry.
Some cases of financial exploitation by loan sharks have been prosecuted under the jurisdiction of the Micro and Small Enterprises Tribunal, which falls under the Micro and Small Enterprises Act of 2012. Greater awareness among public service motorcycle riders is needed urgently to prevent this exploitation, and also guide the youth to seek assistance from the Tribunal when they are exploited.
From customs and law enforcement, the One Stop Border Post in Moyale is well positioned as a hub for scanning and monitoring trucks and buses along the Nairobi-Moyale-Addis Ababa route, and identifying key actors. So too, intelligence sharing and cross-border cooperation among security agencies in Kenya and Ethiopia is an essential component to cracking down on the theft and the operators along the criminal value chain.
Willis Okumu, Senior Researcher – East and Horn of Africa, ENACT Project, ISS